Deena Fink and Frank Innusa opened Anomalia Pizza in September 2025 at 415 South Bethlehem Pike in Fort Washington. It replaced Little Italy in that spot.

The menu includes a variety of pizzas by the pie and slice, calzones and strombolis, salads, and small bites such as meatballs and garlic knots. At the end of 2025, Anomalia was included in The Philadelphia Inquirer article “2025 in pizza: The best new slices and pies in the Philly area.“

About Anomalia from its website:

Take a step back from the on-the-go, feeling and let Anomalia fill you with excitement and the nostalgia of the good old days. The ones where you could just sit and have a slice with the people you love. We take the classic New York slice shop feel, mix it with some unique flavor profiles, personal touches, and some corny Pop-Culture movie references to provide you with a Pizza experience that will make you crave more.

The pizza shop is open Tuesday through Sunday from 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Orders for pickup and delivery can be made online.

Photo: Anomalia/Instagram